How HVCC (Home Valuation Code of Conduct) is Affecting Quality Real Estate Appraisers

It is now a fact that the HVCC that went into effect on May 1, 2009 has changed how lenders and real estate appraisers communicate with regard to single family home loans. Although there are new rules regulating how real estate appraisals are obtained for single family homes, doing business with a time-tested, modern appraisal firm like Allied Appraisal remains in everyone’s best interest. In the first installment of a 3 part series, we will go into how AMC’s (Appraisal Management Companies) have affected the real estate  landscape (not just in Massachusetts, but across the country).

THE APPRAISAL MANAGEMENT COMPANY (AMC)

With the implementation of the new regulations, a new money-making scheme called the “Appraisal Management Company”, or “AMC” began to increase in popularity. The basic premise is this: Preying on the unsuspecting lender, an AMC claims to “provide a firewall between the lender and the appraiser”. They use scare tactics such as “non-compliance with HVCC” if one continues to directly communicate with the appraisers one has been doing business with for years. In order to gain such business, they lower the fee to the appraiser actually doing the work, and increase the fee that they charge the lender (which the lender then passes on to their customer). This takes money out of the pocket of the independent fee appraiser as well as the lender’s customer, while attracting only the appraisers (usually trainees or newly licensed appraisers) that will work for such a low amount. Furthermore, the lender may actually be violating the code without even knowing it by utilizing an AMC, as the code clearly states that the appraiser must be “geographically competent” to appraise a given property. Many times, the only appraisers that will work for the small fees AMC’s provide are driving 100 miles each way just to reach the property. In the end, more inferior appraisals are hitting the street, good appraisers are forced out of the market, and your customers are paying more!

In conclusion, under the Code, lenders are not required to use an AMC. In our opinion, The AMC will fade as quickly as they appeared, and time-tested, experienced appraisal firms will remain. The truth is larger firms such as Allied Appraisal of Worcester, MA meet HVCC with flying colors, and provide lenders and their customers with the quality that has made us a leader in the industry for over 30 years.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

4 Responses to “How HVCC (Home Valuation Code of Conduct) is Affecting Quality Real Estate Appraisers”

  1. John,

    Thanks for posting this on your Website. We need to do more to alert the Consumer of the damage that the HVCC has done to our profession.

    Did you know about this site: http://www.appraisersupport.com/AS/Home.html

    You can log on and upload your fees that you are being paid and also note what the AMC who hired you is charging the consumer.

    This site is run by a member of our on line appraisers forum hosted on Yahoo the InlandCAAppraisersForum. You might want to include a Link to this site on your Page as support for what you are saying so the people who log onto your site can see what the real world is

    Have you received any feedback yet? Let me know what kind of feedback you get.

    John C. Carlson
    CA Certified General Real Estate Appraiser
    Diamond Bar, CA

  2. admin says:

    Thanks, John. I was not aware of that site, but will be sure to check it out. You are correct in that the consumer needs to be aware of these scams, as well as lenders. HVCC needs some serious adjustments, but it’s interpretation is the real problem. I urge that everyone who reads this go to the following link. It is an easy to navigate FAQ direct from Freddie Mac (I’m also going to put a permanent link here on the site:

    http://www.freddiemac.com/singlefamily/hvcc_faq.html

  3. I don’t mean to be “in your face” with this, but let’s just say I definitely have a different view on this. Great post though…

  4. admin says:

    And your point of view is…… ?

Leave a Reply